Speaking but Not Listening; Meeting but Not Engaging



After four days of COP negotiations it’s apparent that parties need to spend less time delivering statements they have prepared in advance and more time listening to and engaging with the statements of others.

Of course, this problem is as old as multilateral diplomacy itself.  Still, that doesn’t mean it can’t be overcome.  The COP Presidency seems to agree and hosted a traditional South African Indaba over the past two days to address the issue.  A meeting held by the Zulu and Xhosa peoples, an Indaba is meant to bring parties together to discuss a matter of great importance to the community, particularly problems that affect everyone, and to solve intractable or difficult collective challenges.  According to the…

Calls for Climate Justice at COP17

As with past climate negotiations in Copenhagen and Cancun, developing countries and developed countries at COP17 in Durban are sharply divided over the future framework for a legally binding treaty for mitigating climate change, and are struggling to operationalize finance mechanisms to help countries adapt to problems like rising sea level, flooding, and drought.

While I’ve spent most of my time at COP17 inside the negotiations as a member of the Maldives delegation, overarching critiques of the process from those representing civil society, youth groups, and indigenous groups have piqued my interest.  These critiques are expressed through side events and demonstrations, and are decrying the snail’s pace of UNFCCC negotiations, highlighting the huge power…

If some of the meetings you are attending are like the ones I’ve been to, there are dozens of people, but only a handful of them actively engage in discussions. Power to those country delegates who want to have their voices heard! I suppose the next best thing is to listen to the discussion, take notes and report back.

However, some meeting participants seem too bored for meeting discussions. It occurred to me that maybe there should be designated seating at each meeting as follows:

  • Last row: for those who intend to be on Facebook
  • Previous to last row: Mobile devices
  • Next row: Email
  • Next row: Twitter
  • And so on, depending on the level of attention.

My most humorous conference moment came…

While the ‘climate negotiations’ keep going, thousand of people wearing fancy clothing are walking in and out of the meeting rooms, drinking latte or espresso, exchanging business cards and using the immaculate bathrooms at the Conference Center. Hundred of volunteers and personnel are working tirelessly to allow the smooth flow of delegates and non-government participants at the COP 17. In each bathroom there is at least one African woman cleaning each square centimeter of floor and walls. Palesa, a young woman from Durban, was resting on the wall with the broom in her hands. She was hired to work from 7:30 am to 7:30 pm every day for two weeks. Her submissive attitude and tired glance encouraged me to talk to her. After a brief introduction I asked her about…

International aviation and shipping represent a growing share of global GHG emissions. With the growing use of airplanes for tourism and of shipping for international globalized trade, miles traveled by both sectors are rapidly increasing, and with them fuel consumption as well.

One of the suggestions on the table to reduce emissions from these sectors, is to charge them with a small levy which would reduce demand for their usage, and raise new revenue for the green climate fund. Thus, a double dividend will be achieved – lowered emissions, and further finance for mitigation and adaptation projects.

At a side vent hosted by the international bodies representing shipping and aviation, they presented their opposition to the levy. The International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) argued that the levy would…

As some of you have probably already read, next year’s COP will be hosted by Qatar, with South Korea hosting a pre-cop ministerial meeting. I would like to point out a few obstacles this decision may pose to the integrity of the intentional climate negotiations.

First and most obviously, de facto splitting the COP means doubling its price, wasting precious time and a lot of emissions on moving certain delegates who accompany the ministers and participate at the cop, staff, and the ministers themselves, who will probably have to arrive at the COP to sign on its results in any case. Not the best example to set when negotiating ghg mitigation efforts.

Second, having the ministers meeting first and professional delegates translating their decisions to elaborate text

We couldn't help but notice the many air conditioners on full blast next to open doors in the Pavilion

Air conditioners on full blast next open doors at the Pavilion

There are many Pavilions and exhibition areas that accompany the climate change conference. Trying to escape the already harsh sun at 9 AM while waiting for one of the other students, I stepped into South Africa’s pavilion. I was immediately blasted with cold air from a row of air conditioners next to the many open entrances. It’s disappointing to see this common practice here where we are trying to solve the problem caused by wasteful behaviors. As environmentalists, we can’t feel guilty about every decision we make. However, we need to incorporate environmental considerations into our decisions…

Bellies and Burkas: Vignettes from COP17

With my first step onto South African soil, I was greeted by a contrast that is seared into my memory.  As rhythmic Indian-infused music played, a line of ladies danced for us in midriff-baring tops and balloon-like skirts in vibrant fabrics.  We paused momentarily to take in the sight  and I noticed a line of women approach from behind the dancers clad from head to toe and faces covered with simple black cloth. Without their eyes visible one can only imagine what they thought of the dance.  The Climate Conference is a chance for the whole world to meet. For two weeks we are attempting to negotiate the cultural, environmental and socioeconomic differences that too often create a divide. If we are lucky…

I grew up in Southern California, so I always hear about the days when the surf is big or when snowstorms hit local ski resorts. Brush fires, earthquakes, and California’s perpetual water shortage have also been on my radar since as long as I can remember. This is about as far as I got in thinking about how climate change affects me — until recently. I knew that I should be cognizant of my carbon footprint, and that deforestation, droughts, and floods disproportionately affect the developing nations where I have traveled and worked. However, I thought that concern for climate change should take a back seat to the world’s more pressing matters — poverty, inequity, conflict, and disease. And frankly, I thought that all of this “going green” talk…

Curious as to what is happening at the current COP conference in Durban, South Africa?  Check out the UNFCCC-Durban portion of this blog.  We have about 20 students working hard as representatives for various countries and groups.  They are blogging about their experiences so you can following along too…